Lahore Dust and A London Sale

Namit Arora Avatar

Shekhar Gupta, editor-in-chief of the Indian Express, remembers Benazir Bhutto (1953-2007):

Bhutto … while she could be exasperating, confused, insecure, loud, immature, vicious, venal, desperate, whatever — one weakness you would never associate with Benazir was physical cowardice …

You have to experience Pakistan’s street politics to understand how chaotic and dangerous it can be. Ours has mellowed hugely in comparison. At the best of times, a popular politician in Pakistan takes huge physical risks. Crowds, chaos, din, drums and dust, just the raw energy of the Pakistani street leaves India far behind. Perhaps it is because of the spasmodic nature of that democratic process, each rally is some kind of mass catharsis. Or, perhaps, as a Pakistan journo once told me, “It is just that we are a mostly Punjabi nation.”

More here.  (Another view from Amit Baruah in the Hindustan Times.)

Category:

Reader Comments


3 responses to “Lahore Dust and A London Sale”

  1. A far more realistic, lucid and readable account of Benazir’s life is the piece by Tariq Ali in the LRB . It is a bracing antidote to all the hagiography. Read it to get a good feel for the ruthless business of politics in Pakistan.

  2. Hagiography is indeed in the air. Years ago, reading Dalrymple’s The Age of Kali, Benazir had struck me as quite a pedestrian thinker. Under pressure to say something nice about her right after her violent death, a few have sensibly zoomed in on her physical courage. It is a whole different issue that so many Pakistanis had pinned their hopes on someone who had no track record, institutional support, or intellectual capacity to deliver on it. Nevertheless, when I heard the news, I felt sorry for the Pakistani people’s loss of hope.

  3. More reasonable assessments of Benazir have emerged: Dalrymple, Tariq Ali, and Hoodbhoy (a brave man whose life I now fear for).

Leave a Reply to NamitCancel reply

Contact us:

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Discover more from Shunya's Notes

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading