Professor Bidyut Chakrabarty provides a brief survey of the tangled coalition politics in the general election now underway in India:
More here.
And below a few election season cartoons from the English-language media:
Professor Bidyut Chakrabarty provides a brief survey of the tangled coalition politics in the general election now underway in India:
More here.
And below a few election season cartoons from the English-language media:
Reader Comments
And some journalists are taking matters in their own hands… or rather, feet!
The tamasha began a couple of months back, and the tamasha goes on, this is the greatest show on earth, and I only wish I was back at at home watching this on eternally entertaining Hindi news channels and not stuck here visiting boring google news thrice a day!! Our elections are something that anyone who loves true complexity cannot afford to ignore.
Having said that, I share very little of the media’s disdain for regionally based coalitions, old hegemonies are being broken here, power is being decentralized(if not in a formal federal structure, than in the way power is held), people have small leaders who they can take on instead of one all encompassing demagogue and while this means catering to regional agendas, it also means no one can have absolute power in India like Mrs. Gandhi did. Never again will a controvertial CONSTITUTIONAL AMMENDMENT be passed in Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha, ratified in 17 states and brought out as a gazette; all within the space of 3 days.
Also, an interesting side thing ( http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/holnus/002200904241916.htm ) that Advani said, if they come to power they will bring a constitutional ammendment that all elections i.e. Lok Sabha, all state assemblies etc will be held in the same election season; somewhat US style, to save money(how much could we be spending on elections anyway). But elections are the only time when Indian(all?) politicians come off their high horses, and do work etc. Five years is too long a time for anybody to be in power without being worried about consequences of their actions or being accountable to anyone. The on and off holding of elections, where a couple of state assemblies go to the polls every year ensures a better and more constant feedback of peoples’ will IMHO. As for the “model code of conduct” argument; politicians have evolved their ways of getting around it and bring goodies to the people before elections. Thoughts ?
Kapil,
Thanks for your note. What you say makes good sense to me, including the point about staggered elections. In many ways, I think democracy in India is more dynamic than in the US. I wrote elsewhere a while back that holding up identity politics as a problem is the standard refrain. For all that is wrong with identity politics, it is also the means by which historically victimized people organize and seek redressal. It is no small blessing to be able to setup a party of your own, champion a community’s cause, pitch your ideas, and ask for their votes.
Leave a Reply