Category: Philosophy
-
Two Articles and a Contest
Here are two recent articles I found thought provoking and insightful (via 3QD). I’d also like to draw your attention to a new contest for the best blog post in Arts & Literature.
Reasoning is generally seen as a mean to improve knowledge and make better decisions. Much evidence, however, shows that reasoning often leads to epistemic distortions and poor decisions. This suggests rethinking the function of reasoning. Our hypothesis is that the function of reasoning is argumentative. It is to devise and evaluate arguments intended to persuade. Reasoning so conceived is adaptive given human exceptional dependence on communication and vulnerability to misinformation. A wide range of evidence in the psychology or reasoning and decision making can be reinterpreted and better explained in the light of this hypothesis. Poor performance in standard reasoning tasks is explained by the lack of argumentative context. When the same problems are placed in a proper argumentative setting, people turn out to be skilled arguers. Skilled arguers, however, are not after the truth but after arguments supporting their views. This explains the notorious confirmation bias. This bias is apparent not only when people are actually arguing but also when they are reasoning proactively with the perspective of having to defend their opinions. Reasoning so motivated can distort evaluations and attitudes and allow the persistence of erroneous beliefs. Proactively used reasoning also favors decisions that are easy to justify but not necessarily better. In all of these instances traditionally described as failures or flaws, reasoning does exactly what can be expected of an argumentative device: look for arguments that support a given conclusion, and favor conclusions in support of which arguments can be found. Category: Philosophy -
Early Islam, Part 5: Epilogue
Part 1: The Rise of Islam / Part 2: The Golden Age of Islam
Part 3: The Path of Reason / Part 4: The Mystic Tide(This five-part series on early Islamic history begins with the rise of Islam, shifts to its golden age, examines two major currents of early Islamic thought—rationalism and Sufi mysticism—and concludes with an epilogue. It builds on precursor essays I wrote at Stanford’s Green Library during a summer sabbatical years ago, and on subsequent travels in Islamic lands of the Middle East and beyond.)
__________________________________________
Muslims discovered Greek thought hundreds of years before the Western Christians, yet it was the latter who eventually domesticated it. Why did the reverse not happen? Why did the golden age of Islam (approx. 9th-12th centuries)—led by luminaries such as al-Kindi, al-Farabi, Alhazen, al-Beruni, Omar Khayyam, Avicenna, and Averroës—wither away? Despite a terrific start, why did Greek rationalism fail to ignite more widely in Islam? In this epilogue, I’ll survey some answers that have been offered by historians and highlight one that I hold the most significant. -
John Gray on the Enlightenment
British philosopher John Gray has critiqued the Enlightenment for years but for once he hits all the right notes in this review:
There is a sect of rationalists who never cease harping on the childishness of religion, and it has to be admitted that there is sometimes something to their complaint. One of the symptoms of a childish mentality – a condition that afflicts adults, not children – is the conviction that things must be either good or bad. Evil can never come from good, it is believed, for the essential nature of good is to be simple and pure. The essence of the Christian religion, for example, is love. In that case, how could Christianity have anything to do with religious warfare or persecution? Such blemishes can only be the result of a perversion of Christian teaching, which in its original purity contained nothing hateful. No doubt much that is odious has been done in its name, but Christianity – the essence or spirit of the religion – is innocent of all evil.This is childish reasoning, if only because it fails to understand that like every religion Christianity is made up from a variety of sources, not all of them wholly benign. Pure Christianity is a figment of fundamentalism, a way of thinking that is typical of the childish mind. But fundamentalism is by no means confined to those who call themselves fundamentalists, or to religious believers. Nowadays it is defenders of the Enlightenment who provide some of the best examples of fundamentalist thinking, and Tzvetan Todorov is a case in point. In this stiff and leaden volume he seeks to rescue the Enlightenment from distortions. He does so in the faith that once it has been properly understood no one – no one who is not fanatical, deluded or ill-willing, at any rate – can fail to accept the Enlightenment’s essential message.
-
Michael Sandel on Justice
“Hundreds of students pack Harvard’s Sanders Theater for Michael Sandel‘s “Justice” course—an introduction to moral and political
philosophy. They come to hear Sandel lecture about great philosophers
of the past—from Aristotle to John Stuart Mill—but also to debate
contemporary issues that raise philosophical questions—about individual
rights and the claims of community, equality and inequality, morality
and law.” Below is the first lecture of his popular course. Additional ones can be viewed as they are made available here in the weeks ahead.More Sandel? Check out his excellent BBC Reith Lecture from earlier this year, A New Citizenship. Also check out Justice: A Journey in Moral Reasoning, and The Case Against Perfection: What’s Wrong with Designer Children, Bionic Athletes, and Genetic Engineering.
-
Language on the Philosopher’s Zone
“Ray Monk from the University of Southampton in the UK is something
unusual in philosophers of the English-speaking world: he’s a
biographer…. he tell us about the challenges of writing the
lives of Bertrand Russell and of the great Ludwig Wittgenstein and why he thinks that biography is a very Wittgensteinian genre.”
“We continue our look at translation by
examining the extreme case of radical translation. How do you translate
from a language which has no connection with yours and of which you do
not speak a single word, and what does all this have to do with the
mysterious word ‘gavagai’? We also look at
the challenges of translating philosophy this week focusing on
translating French, German and English.”Category: PhilosophyAsia on the Philosopher’s Zone
“For a long while, Western philosophy has had little to do with the philosophical traditions of India and China. A common view … was that all thought in the Asian traditions was not philosophy, but religion or mysticism. But now, slowly, Western philosophers are starting to engage with Asian thought … Graham Priest, Professor of Philosophy at Melbourne University, talks about what these philosophers are finding there, and why it’s often challenging for someone who knows only Western philosophy.”Category: PhilosophyNicholas Maxwell on Science
Here is a thought-provoking podcast with British philosopher of science, Nicholas Maxwell. He has devoted much of his working life trying to get across the point that we urgently need to bring about a revolution in the aims and methods of academic inquiry, so the basic aim becomes the promotion of wisdom by rational means rather than just the acquisition of knowledge, for knowledge without wisdom, or science without civilization, is extremely dangerous. We now have this problem, he believes, because … well, listen for yourself (~52 minutes).Becoming Me
A charming story of creation (mostly a modern retelling of a Hindu one; might have been better without the final line, “but even then…”).
On Knowledge Without Wisdom
(Cross-posted on 3 Quarks Daily.)
The Greeks understood philosophy as the love of wisdom. They valued theoretical knowledge to the extent it contributed to practical wisdom. Inside Plato’s Academy was a grove of olive trees dedicated to Athena, the goddess of wisdom. But philosophy today, at least as pursued by much of the Anglo-American academy, is markedly different. For the most part, its concerns have shrunk to sub-disciplines in epistemology, paving the way for the acquisition of theoretical knowledge as an end in itself. The pursuit of wisdom seems to have left the academy and alighted on the stormy shores of self-help aisles.The First Philosophy
Hilary Putnam on Science
Here is Hilary Putnam, American mathematician, philosopher of science, and a central figure in analytic philosophy, in conversation with Bryan Magee. Dating from the 80s, I recommend this for all those who wish to challenge and broaden their understanding of science, objective truth, and the scientific method. Part one appears below, here are two, three, four, and five (total ~45 mins).
Critchley on Heidegger
Continuing with this blog’s recent focus on Heidegger, here is a “plain English” account of why Heidegger matters and what his magnum opus, Being and Time, is all about. This is a series of articles in the Guardian by Simon Critchley: one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight.
Martin Heidegger (1889-1976) was the most important and influential philosopher in the continental tradition in the 20th century. Being and Time, first published in 1927, was his magnum opus. There is no way of understanding what took place in continental philosophy
after Heidegger without coming to terms with Being and Time.
Furthermore, unlike many Anglo-American philosophers, Heidegger has
exerted a huge influence outside philosophy, in areas as diverse as
architecture, contemporary art, social and political theory,
psychotherapy, psychiatry and theology….Being and Time is a work of considerable length (437 pages in the German original) and legendary difficulty. The difficulty is caused by the fact that Heidegger sets himself the task of what he calls a “destruction” of the philosophical tradition. We shall see some of the implications of this in future entries, but the initial consequence is that Heidegger refuses to avail himself of the standard terminology of modern philosophy, with its talk of epistemology, subjectivity, representation, objective knowledge and the rest.
Category: PhilosophyAlan de Botton on Success
Here is a breezy talk in which Alain de Botton looks at our ideas of success and failure, the anxiety we feel over our careers, why it’s harder now to feel calm than ever before. Is success always earned? Is failure? What role does snobbery and envy play in our lives? What is the flip side of equality, individualism, and meritocracy? Where do our goals and ambitions really come from? And more (via 3QD).
Heidegger on Nihilism, Art, Technology, and Politics
This is a classic essay from Dreyfus on how Heidegger saw the connection between nihilism, art, technology and politics:
When everything that is material and social has become completely flat and drab, people retreat into their private experiences as the only remaining place to find significance. Heidegger sees this move to private experience as characteristic of the modern age. Art, religion, sex, education all becomes varieties of experiences. When all our concerns have been reduced to the common denominator of “experience” we will have reached the last stage of nihilism. One then sees “the plunge into frenzy and the disintegration into sheer feeling as redemptive. The `lived experience’ as such becomes decisive.”That is, when there are no shared examples of greatness that focus public concerns and elicit social commitment, people become spectators of fads and public lives, just for the excitement. When there are no religious practices that call forth sacrifice, terror, and awe, people consume everything from drugs to meditation practices to give themselves some kind of peak experience. The peak experience takes the place of what was once a relation to something outside the self that defined the real and was therefore holy. As Heidegger puts it:
Category: PhilosophyAnalytic vs. Continental Philosophy
Brian Leiter’s take on the two major traditions of philosophy in the western world: Analytic and Continental philosophy:
“Analytic” philosophy today names a style of doing philosophy, not a philosophical program or a set of substantive views. Analytic philosophers, crudely speaking, aim for argumentative clarity and precision; draw freely on the tools of logic; and often identify, professionally and intellectually, more closely with the sciences and mathematics, than with the humanities…. The foundational figures of this tradition are philosophers like Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell, the young Ludwig Wittgenstein and G.E. Moore; other canonical figures include Carnap, Quine, Davidson, Kripke, Rawls, Dummett, and Strawson…“Continental” philosophy, by contrast, demarcates a group of (primarily) French and German philosophers of the 19th and 20th centuries…. The foundational figure of this tradition is usually thought to be Hegel; other canonical figures include the other post-Kantian German Idealists (e.g., Fichte, Schelling), Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard, Marx, Nietzsche, Husserl, Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty, Sartre, Gadamer, Horkheimer, Adorno, Marcuse, Habermas, and Foucault. Continental philosophy is sometimes distinguished by its style (more literary, less analytical, less reliant on formal logic), its concerns (more interested in actual political and cultural issues and, loosely speaking, the human situation and its “meaning”), and some of its substantive commitments (more self-conscious about the relation of philosophy to its historical situation).
Category: Philosophy






